The story
Old Wild West on V. Aurelia in Rome positions itself as a classic American steakhouse, earning a 4.1-star rating with a family-friendly, old-school vibe and outdoor seating. It’s a casual spot that leans into tourist-friendly comfort, but one creator dug into its attempt at the trendy Smash Burger.
Giuliacrossbow, in her video “VENDERE SMASH BURGER NON È OBBLIGATORIO,” called the American Smash Burger a parmesan-heavy, unbalanced mess that “has nothing to do with a real Smash Burger.” For those seeking an authentic smash experience, this Rome outpost might miss the mark.
Synthesised by AI from every creator’s review. First reviewed 2025.
Most-loved dishes
AI summary of what 1 dish mentions say about the food
Old Wild West’s American smash burger earns rave reviews for its juicy, charred patty, while the overall vibe is casual, hearty, and satisfyingly indulgent.
“This is supposed to be a Smash Burger, but it has none of the characteristics of a Smash Burger. There's a bit of Maillard reaction on top, but it looks really bad. The patty is thin but completely overshadowed by an absurd amount of parmesan sauce — it tastes like cacio e pepe, I can't taste anything else. The meat is completely impersonal. The bacon has a nice crunchy part, but overall the burger is totally unbalanced. It's not a bad sandwich, you can eat it, but it's not a Smash Burger.”
What creators say
1 creator has covered Old Wild West. Most active: Giuliacrossbow
Old Wild West tries to ride the Smash Burger trend, but the result is a parmesan-heavy, unbalanced burger that has nothing to do with a real Smash Burger.
Dishes mentioned
- Smash Burger
